Jaipur:** In a significant ruling for taxpayers, the Jaipur Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has granted relief to a man who faced tax proceedings over a property purchase worth ₹20.23 lakh and cash deposits of ₹13.04 lakh.
The tribunal accepted his explanation that the money deposited in his bank account came from a cash gift of ₹16 lakh given by his mother after selling her old gold jewellery. The decision highlights the importance of maintaining proper financial records and documentary evidence when receiving substantial gifts from family members.
### Why Did the Income Tax Department Question the Transactions?
The case involved a taxpayer named Jhutha Ram, who had made an investment of ₹20,23,778 in immovable property and deposited ₹13,04,900 in cash into his bank account during the relevant financial year.
As he had not initially filed an income tax return for Assessment Year 2012–13, the department reopened his assessment and sought an explanation for these transactions.
The assessing officer treated both the property investment and cash deposits as unexplained amounts. However, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) subsequently deleted the addition relating to the property purchase while retaining the ₹13.04 lakh addition concerning cash deposits.
The taxpayer then approached the ITAT Jaipur for further relief.
### Mother Sold 642 Grams of Gold to Gift ₹16 Lakh
During the tribunal proceedings, the taxpayer explained that his mother had sold approximately 642.3 grams of old gold jewellery for ₹16,10,567.
She subsequently gifted ₹16 lakh to her son on February 2, 2012. The taxpayer submitted a notarised gift deed bearing two witnesses' signatures, along with a valuation report prepared by a registered valuer.
The jewellery had been valued at approximately ₹18.36 lakh as of March 31, 2011.
The Income Tax Department had questioned the transaction because the jewellery sale invoice did not contain individual descriptions of the ornaments and the sale proceeds had not first been deposited into the mother's bank account.
The taxpayer argued that old jewellery transactions commonly record the total weight rather than providing individual descriptions of each ornament.
### ITAT Accepts Documentary Evidence and Deletes ₹13.04 Lakh Addition
After examining the available documents and submissions, the Jaipur ITAT found the taxpayer's explanation acceptable.
The tribunal noted that the gift deed clearly established the transfer of ₹16 lakh from the mother to her son. It also considered the jewellery valuation report and the signatures of two witnesses on the notarised gift deed.
The tribunal observed that a gift received from a mother falls within the category of gifts from relatives under the Income Tax Act.
Consequently, it held that the cash gift could not be doubted in the circumstances of the case and directed the deletion of the ₹13,04,900 addition made towards unexplained cash deposits.
The tribunal pronounced its order on October 6, 2026, allowing the taxpayer's appeal.
### Important Lesson for Taxpayers
The ruling highlights why people receiving substantial financial gifts from parents or other relatives should maintain proper documentation.
Gift deeds, jewellery sale receipts, valuation reports and bank statements can help establish the identity of the donor, the genuineness of the gift and the original source of funds.
Although gifts from specified relatives are generally exempt from income tax, taxpayers may still be asked to explain the source of substantial deposits during scrutiny.
The case serves as an important reminder that maintaining clear financial records can help prevent unnecessary tax disputes.